jah128 is offlineAdd to jah128's Reputation
jah128's Avatar
jah128
Solar Flare
Join Date: Mar 2007
Posts: 3633

(Too many word games?) Splitting the misc forum discussion...

POSTED BY: jah128 4 months, 1 week ago

(Edited 9/7) This thread started out as a discussion over the number of word games but its really a thread now about why (myself and some others think) we should split the misc forum in some manner.

The first problem is that the number of word-games, quizzes, jokes, congratulations posts and other random stuff has grown rapidly recently, and the nature of these threads is such that they are often bumped to the top of the page regularly as they attract a number of responses. I have no problem with them at all, but misc also contains threads on useful tips, help requests, questions about how the site works and occasionally some really good (serious) discussion threads.

The other problem is that the misc forum allows threads to contain nonsense, be driven wildly off-topic, contain in-jokes and spam posts etc. Again, this is fine, but its a real shame when these ruin what could otherwise be a really useful thread, and it would be nice to have a forum where people can ask a question or even a debate without loads of spam and off-topic replies.

This thread contains some interesting ideas on how such a split could be achieved, it would be good if more users gave there feedback on whether they think a split would be a good idea, potential names for the split-forum or any other possible solutions.

Tags: , (Add a tag)



jah128 is offline  
jah128's Avatar
jah128
Solar Flare
jah128 is heating upjah128 is heating upjah128 is heating upjah128 is heating upjah128 is heating upjah128 is heating upjah128 is heating upjah128 is heating upjah128 is heating upjah128 is heating upjah128 is heating up
 
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: Sunnyvale Trailer Park
Posts: 3,633
View FS/FT Feedback
http://www.hotukdeals.com/item/17273...-another-game/

This one in particular seems pointless...
Reply With Quote
Sheriff Waffles is offline  
Sheriff Waffles's Avatar
Sheriff Waffles
Solar Flare
Sheriff Waffles has a reputation beyond reputeSheriff Waffles has a reputation beyond reputeSheriff Waffles has a reputation beyond reputeSheriff Waffles has a reputation beyond reputeSheriff Waffles has a reputation beyond reputeSheriff Waffles has a reputation beyond reputeSheriff Waffles has a reputation beyond reputeSheriff Waffles has a reputation beyond reputeSheriff Waffles has a reputation beyond reputeSheriff Waffles has a reputation beyond reputeSheriff Waffles has a reputation beyond repute
 
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: ON PATROL
Posts: 2,220
View FS/FT Feedback
Me gets the feelin' you never win at scrabble ...
Reply With Quote
Send a message via MSN to bellabonkers
bellabonkers is offline  
bellabonkers's Avatar
bellabonkers
Solar Flare
bellabonkers is getting a little spicybellabonkers is getting a little spicybellabonkers is getting a little spicybellabonkers is getting a little spicybellabonkers is getting a little spicybellabonkers is getting a little spicybellabonkers is getting a little spicybellabonkers is getting a little spicybellabonkers is getting a little spicybellabonkers is getting a little spicybellabonkers is getting a little spicy
 
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: Newcastle upon Tyne
Posts: 5,067
View FS/FT Feedback
jah128:
http://www.hotukdeals.com/item/17273...-another-game/

This one in particular seems pointless...
I know what you mean but i didnt want to be the one saying something. Some people get a bit bolshy and i can't be bothered with it lol
Reply With Quote
jah128 is offline  
jah128's Avatar
jah128
Solar Flare
jah128 is heating upjah128 is heating upjah128 is heating upjah128 is heating upjah128 is heating upjah128 is heating upjah128 is heating upjah128 is heating upjah128 is heating upjah128 is heating upjah128 is heating up
 
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: Sunnyvale Trailer Park
Posts: 3,633
View FS/FT Feedback
Sheriff Waffles:
Me gets the feelin' you never win at scrabble ...
Scrabble is my game, but thats not really what happens in the scrabble threads is it...

bellabonkers:
I know what you mean but i didnt want to be the one saying something. Some people get a bit bolshy and i can't be bothered with it lol
Its just got to a point where half the visible misc forum page is essentially duplicates of the same thing. Theres the word association and count to a million which have been going for ages, and the original scrabble game, but do we really need the other new scrabble games (3 letter and the other one started "because the old one got too long"?)

Last edited by jah128 : 18-04-2008 at 18:20.
Reply With Quote
nikkib123 is offline  
nikkib123's Avatar
nikkib123
Solar Flare
nikkib123 is heating upnikkib123 is heating upnikkib123 is heating upnikkib123 is heating upnikkib123 is heating upnikkib123 is heating upnikkib123 is heating upnikkib123 is heating upnikkib123 is heating upnikkib123 is heating upnikkib123 is heating up
 
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: In my house
Posts: 1,698
View FS/FT Feedback
I don't mind them at all (but I would say that ha ha), I stick to the same 2, my scrabble one and pinkkitty's name one.
I can see your point but I don't think its so bad - there are worse things on here.
Reply With Quote
Send a message via MSN to bellabonkers
bellabonkers is offline  
bellabonkers's Avatar
bellabonkers
Solar Flare
bellabonkers is getting a little spicybellabonkers is getting a little spicybellabonkers is getting a little spicybellabonkers is getting a little spicybellabonkers is getting a little spicybellabonkers is getting a little spicybellabonkers is getting a little spicybellabonkers is getting a little spicybellabonkers is getting a little spicybellabonkers is getting a little spicybellabonkers is getting a little spicy
 
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: Newcastle upon Tyne
Posts: 5,067
View FS/FT Feedback
spam and expire the new ones then???
Reply With Quote
jah128 is offline  
jah128's Avatar
jah128
Solar Flare
jah128 is heating upjah128 is heating upjah128 is heating upjah128 is heating upjah128 is heating upjah128 is heating upjah128 is heating upjah128 is heating upjah128 is heating upjah128 is heating upjah128 is heating up
 
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: Sunnyvale Trailer Park
Posts: 3,633
View FS/FT Feedback
nikkib123:
I don't mind them at all (but I would say that ha ha), I stick to the same 2, my scrabble one and pinkkitty's name one.
I can see your point but I don't think its so bad - there are worse things on here.
I don't mind the games at all (forgot about the name game one) - I've participated in most of them, but surely just 1 scrabble game is enough (that would leave the 4 - scrabble, word-association, name and count to a million)... Like you say though, its a small point and I'm sure they will die a natural death soon enough anyway...

bellabonkers:
spam and expire the new ones then???
I feel that would be an abuse of power, it is the miscellaneous nonsense forum after all and I don't think they break any site rules...
The only reason its an issue at all is because they fill up the top half of the page, causing undue wear to my trackpad due to the amount i have to scroll

Last edited by jah128 : 18-04-2008 at 18:26.
Reply With Quote
nikkib123 is offline  
nikkib123's Avatar
nikkib123
Solar Flare
nikkib123 is heating upnikkib123 is heating upnikkib123 is heating upnikkib123 is heating upnikkib123 is heating upnikkib123 is heating upnikkib123 is heating upnikkib123 is heating upnikkib123 is heating upnikkib123 is heating upnikkib123 is heating up
 
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: In my house
Posts: 1,698
View FS/FT Feedback
jah128:
I don't mind the games at all (forgot about the name game one) - I've participated in most of them, but surely just 1 scrabble game is enough (that would leave the 4 - scrabble, word-association, name and count to a million)... Like you say though, its a small point and I'm sure they will die a natural death soon enough anyway...
Valid point though
Reply With Quote
Admin is offline  
Admin's Avatar
Admin
Administrator
Admin has disabled reputation
 
Join Date: Aug 2004
Posts: 12,382
View FS/FT Feedback
Maybe the "owner" of the original ones can pm a mod when it gets too big and the mod can lock the old one with a link on last msg to the new one.
Reply With Quote
Send a message via AIM to highguyuk
highguyuk is offline  
highguyuk's Avatar
highguyuk
Solar Flare
highguyuk is heating uphighguyuk is heating uphighguyuk is heating uphighguyuk is heating uphighguyuk is heating uphighguyuk is heating uphighguyuk is heating uphighguyuk is heating uphighguyuk is heating uphighguyuk is heating uphighguyuk is heating up
 
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: UK
Posts: 2,684
View FS/FT Feedback
I think its a bit OTT too, but dont wish to be a spoilsport.

I was thinking though that on quite a few forums I'm a member of, posts in certain sections don't count towards the post count. Now, obviously this couldn't be implemented on the misc forum as a whole - but maybe something to think about.
Reply With Quote
Send a message via MSN to guv
guv is offline  
guv's Avatar
guv
Solar Flare
guv is getting a little spicyguv is getting a little spicyguv is getting a little spicyguv is getting a little spicyguv is getting a little spicyguv is getting a little spicyguv is getting a little spicyguv is getting a little spicyguv is getting a little spicyguv is getting a little spicyguv is getting a little spicy
 
Join Date: May 2007
Posts: 6,985
View FS/FT Feedback
Are people really that obsessed to get their post count up? It often seems that way. Some of the threads referred really have no point or value whatsoever.

I just ignore them to be honest.
Reply With Quote
MoneySavingG is offline  
MoneySavingG
Solar Flare
MoneySavingG has a reputation beyond reputeMoneySavingG has a reputation beyond reputeMoneySavingG has a reputation beyond reputeMoneySavingG has a reputation beyond reputeMoneySavingG has a reputation beyond reputeMoneySavingG has a reputation beyond reputeMoneySavingG has a reputation beyond reputeMoneySavingG has a reputation beyond reputeMoneySavingG has a reputation beyond reputeMoneySavingG has a reputation beyond reputeMoneySavingG has a reputation beyond repute
 
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: Serious, Moi?
Posts: 1,260
View FS/FT Feedback
..and jokes.
There ideal solution would be a subdivision of the misc forums, serious/help/rant and pointle..sorry, non-serious.
Reply With Quote
Send a message via MSN to black gerbil1
black gerbil1 is offline  
black gerbil1's Avatar
black gerbil1
Solar Flare
black gerbil1 is getting a little spicyblack gerbil1 is getting a little spicyblack gerbil1 is getting a little spicyblack gerbil1 is getting a little spicyblack gerbil1 is getting a little spicyblack gerbil1 is getting a little spicyblack gerbil1 is getting a little spicyblack gerbil1 is getting a little spicyblack gerbil1 is getting a little spicyblack gerbil1 is getting a little spicyblack gerbil1 is getting a little spicy
 
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: influencing the misc since 07
Posts: 5,845
View FS/FT Feedback
just keep that Word association game delete the rest....jus sayin
Reply With Quote
jah128 is offline  
jah128's Avatar
jah128
Solar Flare
jah128 is heating upjah128 is heating upjah128 is heating upjah128 is heating upjah128 is heating upjah128 is heating upjah128 is heating upjah128 is heating upjah128 is heating upjah128 is heating upjah128 is heating up
 
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: Sunnyvale Trailer Park
Posts: 3,633
View FS/FT Feedback
Not suggesting they should all be removed, and I really don't think the post count issue matters, but just as moneysavingg suggests it would to have a decluttered 'serious' misc forum, or a limit on the number of 'pointless' threads...
Reply With Quote

Thread Tools